To Be Kind or to Be Kind

Kindness is more than what we do; it's who we become. A heartfelt reflection on compassion, self-love, boundaries, and the quiet power of living with kindness rather than simply performing it.

To Be Kind or to Be Kind

On the Difference Between Trying to Be Kind and Being Kindness Itself

By Rachel Y. Hill, DNP, FNP-BC, PMHNP-BC, AHN-BC, HWNC-BC


I want to explore an idea that is simple to say and surprisingly hard to explain: there is a difference between trying to be kind and being kindness.

They can look identical from the outside.

Someone holds the door. Someone brings soup. Someone says the gentle thing at the hard moment.

But I have come to believe that they come from two very different places, and that the place you act from changes everything, including how you see the people in front of you.

Two Ways to Read It

Look at two words: being kind.

Read it one way and it's an action.

Being kind is something you do: a favor, a compliment, a casserole. It's a verb wearing a nice outfit. You can do it on Tuesday and be finished by Wednesday.

Read it another way and it's a state of being.

Being kind is something you are. It isn't a thing you do so much as a place you live, the water you swim in.

It colors everything you do, including the things that don't look kind at all, like setting a boundary or telling someone the truth.

Same two words. Two completely different meanings.

To be kind, or to be kind: that is the question.

The action version is where most of us begin. The state version is where the magic is.

"But I'm Not Unkind"

Most of us were raised to be kind to others: to say please and thank you, to share, to be polite.

And a lot of us quietly decided that we pass the test because of what we don't do.

I don't yell. I don't gossip. I don't cheat anyone. I don't hurt people. So I'm a kind person.

I've come to believe that not being unkind is not the same as being kind.

Staying out of harm's way is a good start, but it's the floor, not the whole house.

Kindness isn't only the absence of the bad thing. It's the presence of something warm.

And here's what I think we miss: kindness is not just going out of your way to do something big.

It comes in many kinds. Here are some of them.

  • Kindness of attention. Putting the phone down. Looking someone in the eye. Really listening, without waiting for your turn to talk. Being truly present is one of the rarest gifts we can give.
  • Kindness of tone. The same words land very differently depending on the voice behind them. A gentle tone can turn a correction into care.
  • Kindness of patience. Giving someone time to find the word or learn the thing, without sighing.
  • Kindness of restraint. Not saying the clever, cutting thing. Not repeating what you heard. Not correcting someone in front of others. Sometimes the kindest act is the thing you chose not to do.
  • Kindness of honesty. Telling the truth with care. Real kindness isn't flattery, and it isn't avoiding hard conversations. It's saying the true thing in a way the person can hear.
  • Kindness of thought. Assuming the best and remembering that you don't know what someone is carrying. This one happens where nobody can see it, and it shapes all the rest.
  • Kindness of boundaries. A loving "no." Protecting your time and energy so you can show up for the people you love without resentment.
  • Kindness of grace. Forgiving, letting go, giving someone a second chance, including the ones who didn't ask for it.
  • Kindness to the unseen. The server, the cashier, the cleaning crew, anyone who can never repay you.
  • Kindness in receiving. Letting someone else feel the joy of giving.
  • Kindness to yourself. The inner voice, the rest you allow, the mistakes you forgive. Most of us hand out kindness to everyone but the person we spend the most time with.

Almost none of that requires a grand gesture.

Most of it can be done sitting down, for free, in under a minute.

So we have far more chances to be kind than we think.

That's not meant to make you feel guilty.

It's an invitation: where is there room for something warm?

The Nicety Trap

Hiding underneath "I'm not unkind" is something I call a nicety.

It's a word I use for the best of nice and nasty at the same time.

You know it when you meet it.

It's the "bless your heart" that isn't a blessing. The compliment with a little sting tucked inside. The big smile over clenched teeth. The "no offense, but." The favor done loudly, so everyone knows what you sacrificed.

It has all the right words and the wrong music.

So what good does a nicety do anyone?

Very little.

People can feel when the words and the heart don't match. They may not be able to say what's off, but they sense it, and it leaves them guarded instead of warmed.

It costs the giver, too, because it takes a lot of energy to hold a smile on the outside and a grudge on the inside.

A nicety is kindness that didn't start in the heart. And kindness that doesn't start there rarely gets where it's going.

Two Places to Start From

Think about the phrase trying to be kind.

Notice what's in it.

There is a me who is trying, and a kindness that is somewhere out there to be reached.

A gap sits between the two, and effort is how I cross it.

Trying to be kind is a good thing. I want to say that first, loudly.

Every one of us starts here, and a kind act done through effort is still a kind act.

But trying has a flavor.

It carries a little tension: Am I doing this right? Did they notice? Was that enough?

It can keep a quiet score.

It's tiring, because anything you have to produce on command eventually runs out.

And it's fragile, because when the person is rude, or the day is long, or I'm running on empty, the trying stops.

Now think about being kindness.

There's no gap. There's no me over here and kindness over there.

Kindness is simply what I'm made of in that moment, and what comes out is whatever the moment calls for.

It doesn't need to be noticed. It isn't keeping score.

And it doesn't run out in the same way, because it isn't something I'm producing.

It's something I'm being.

The Lamp

Here is the picture that helps me.

Imagine a lamp.

A lamp doesn't try to give light, and it doesn't wonder whether anyone noticed.

It's simply lit, and light spills out in every direction, onto the people who are nice to the lamp and the ones who aren't.

Now imagine a person holding a flashlight and carefully choosing where to point it.

Maybe they're pointing it at the people who deserve it, or at the right moments, or at the places where someone will see them doing it.

The flashlight is useful. But it takes effort to hold, it runs on batteries, and it only lights one spot at a time.

Trying to be kind is the flashlight. Being kindness is the lamp.

Neither is bad. Sometimes you need a flashlight.

But I'd rather become a lamp, because the lamp changes the whole room, and it doesn't wear its holder out.

Beyond Effort

Here is where I may take this to another plane, and I'm okay if only some of you follow.

Being kind as an action is driven by something: a motive, a directive, a "should."

It's effort, and it's what I'd call three-dimensional effort.

I push, I plan, I measure, I try, in the world of doing.

That kind of kindness can only take us so far, because effort runs out.

It's the flashlight again.

The state of being kind feels to me like something beyond that.

Many traditions speak of higher dimensions or levels of awareness, and I think of being kindness as living from the fourth or fifth of them: less about doing and more about embodying.

In that place, you aren't producing kindness.

You're standing in it, and it moves through you.

This is my perspective as a holistic practitioner, not a scientific claim, offered as an invitation to be curious.

If the language doesn't speak to you, the lamp will do just fine.

What I've Noticed in Myself

I'll be honest about how this showed up for me.

I wrote earlier about a world that so often shows us what's missing, and about how easy it is to look out and see what isn't there: what's unkind, what's wrong, what needs fixing.

I have to catch myself doing it.

And I realized something about my own kindness: if I'm not careful, it turns into a project.

When kindness becomes a project, it becomes calculated.

I plan the act, do the act, and tuck it away as a good deed done, and a tiny part of me quietly collects credit.

I'd rather be honest about that.

What I want is the opposite.

I don't want to walk into the world with a list of kind acts to complete.

I want kindness and love to prompt me, the way a breeze moves a branch.

No performance, nothing to post to show how wonderful I am.

Just the thing that was needed, done because I was there and it was the loving thing to do.

Why It Changes How You See People

Here's the part I find most remarkable, and the part I most want you to try for yourself.

When I'm trying to be kind, I'm also sizing people up.

Is this person worth my kindness? Will they appreciate it?

Underneath, I'm still looking through a filter of judgment.

But when I'm being kindness, I stop evaluating and start noticing.

The short-tempered person in line looks less like a villain and more like someone who might be scared, or exhausted, or hurting.

The difficult relative looks like a person doing the best they know how with what they were handed.

I have come to believe that we tend to get what we are looking for.

If I go out looking for what's wrong, I'll find plenty.

If I go out as kindness, people reveal themselves differently.

They soften. Sometimes they surprise me.

And whether or not they change, I am changed, because I get to live in a world full of people instead of a world full of problems.

When there's nothing to extract, not approval, not credit, not even a thank you, you're free to just see them.

A Picture of the Difference

Let me paint two small scenes.

These are pictures, not stories about anyone in particular.

Scene One

Someone at the grocery store sees an older man struggling to reach a jar.

They think, I should help. That would be the kind thing to do.

They get the jar, smile, and walk away feeling a little virtuous.

Scene Two

Someone relaxed and present simply notices the man reaching.

There's no thought of being kind.

A hand is needed and a hand is available, so the jar is down, a few friendly words are exchanged, and they're already on to the next thing.

Nearly the same from the outside, worlds apart on the inside.

The first act was about the doer. The second was about the moment.

But What About the Days I Don't Feel It?

I would be misleading you if I made this sound effortless, because it isn't.

Some days I'm tired and short and not as patient as I'd like.

On those days, trying is exactly what's required, and it's good.

Trying to be kind is the bridge.

It's how we build the muscle that eventually becomes second nature.

And being kindness doesn't mean being a doormat.

A lamp has a switch.

Real kindness includes boundaries and kindness to yourself.

If you're running on empty, being kindness might mean saying "no" gently, resting, or asking for help.

You can't light a room with a lamp that isn't plugged into anything.

So I don't think of it as trying versus being.

I think of it as a path. We start by trying, and over time, with practice and grace, we come home to being.

How to Get There

No formula, but here is what has helped me.

  • Start with yourself. Love begins with me, and it begins with you. Be gentle with your own mistakes, and notice how your inner voice talks to you.
  • Slow down enough to notice. Kindness is often a response to something you saw. Take a breath before you walk into a room.
  • Drop the scorecard. Next time you do something kind, let it go without telling anyone, or even yourself.
  • Get curious instead of critical. When someone is difficult, silently ask, What might be going on for them? Just asking changes your posture.
  • Let the moment lead. Instead of planning a kind deed, ask, What does this moment need? and see what comes.
  • Fill the lamp. Rest, joy, laughter, the things that remind you who you are. A full person gives from overflow. And on the days it doesn't work, forgive yourself and come back tomorrow.

One Last Thing

I think this is what the world is quietly asking for.

Not more kind acts to add to the pile, but more people who are kindness, so at home in it that the world can't help but warm up around them.

My hope, for me and for you, is that we stop trying to be kind and let ourselves become it.

That we walk through our days like lamps, lighting whatever is nearby, and not needing to know who noticed.

And then we get to see what everyone looks like in the light.

Reflection Questions

  1. When was the last time you did something kind without anyone knowing, and without telling yourself you'd done it?
  2. Where in your life is kindness still a project or a performance?
  3. Who is one person you've been sizing up instead of seeing? What might you notice if you were curious about them?

--Dr. Rachel